In Korea, there were several martial arts groups after independence
from theJapanese. All wanted to get recognized. General Choi being in the
military had the dominance and called it TKD, and tried to unify all
factions into his style called Oh Do Kwan and ITF. He failed and another
rival organization WTF led by
Dr. Un Young Kim, with backing from the civilian government succeeded in
unifying all the TKD factions. General Choi courts South Korean government
to support his organization, but is turned down. He then courts North
Korean government, gets support but also leads to the weakening of his
ITF organization by massive departure of his subordinates. WTF takes this
opportunity and takes the void left by ITF and leads as the official
governing body of TKD .
The WTF emphasis is on tournaments, ITF on traditional TKD in sense of the
martial art . NEITHER IS BETTER THAN THE OTHER. Most students are not
really interested in the politics unless blindly swayed by their
instructors or are not exposed to both styles. The future trend for TKD
appears to be growing into a versatile martial art, which Gen. Choi
achieved briefly in the military in the 70s before its decline. But
whether WTF/ITF or other TKD organization, it is slowly getting there. The
trend speaks for itself; just about all the WTF Korean gold medalists in
the Olympics had multiple BBs in other martial arts; and year after year,
more and more weapons and hapkido techniques are demonstrated by the WTF
demonstration teams.
The
Olympic acceptance
In
Korea, the remaining TKD factions that lost out to General Choi
underwent a significant reform. WTF was formed about the same time ITF was
formed. Impeded by internal politics and lack of international experience,
pre-WTF organizations tried to create a network like ITF with little
progress. But WTF did carry out a massive reform of TKD in Korea to
distinguish itself from ITF and also as an anti-General Choi style
campaign. It created the Pal Geh forms; the ITF styles and movements were
phased out in the military. The military modified the ITF TKD moves with a
speedier movements and more incorporation of
WTF movements and philosophy. The TKD terms were changed from ITF s terms
such as soodoh (knife-hand) of Japanese origin to sohn-kahl , hah dahn
mahki (low block) into ah rae mahki , dae ryun (sparring) into gyorugi
into pure Korean words. Some other terms are also changed. The patterns
are now called poomse instead of hyung . The WTF and ITF separately try
to enter the Olympics but is stalemated.
Strengthened by the weakening ITF, WTF did a massive campaign to capture
the void left by lack of leadership in world TKD arena. Korean government
appoints a new man for the task, Dr. Un-Yong Kim.
Dr. Kim, an academic scholar with several graduate degrees from both in
Korea and the USA was a man of action for the job. A speaker of 6
languages, a seasoned former diplomat, excellent people skills, and with
strong political ties both domestic and abroad, was a doer. As a
director of 100% government backed WTF, he united some 36+ TKD
factions(big and small) in Korea under one banner by organizing a
non-biased governing body. A feat Gen. Choi tried to accomplish over two
decades was done in matter of few years. Most important of
all, he built the WTF(Kukkiwon) headquarters building within a year to
edify WTF by securing support from private sectors through sheer
diplomacy. His work encountered initial resistance and alienated some
heads of different TKD stylists, but his unpretentious loyalty to the
heads of different factions and connections facilitated the creation of a
civilian backed WTF.
The acceptance of WTF TKD into the Olympics as an demonstration sport in
1988 was also through the diplomacy of Dr. Kim. The demonstration
itself became a catalyst for the legitimate acceptance and growth of WTF
TKD by the world. The real TKD sanctioned by WTF spreads via the
television broadcast of Olympics
to the world media is etched into the world viewers as WTF = real TKD.
From this point on, WTF begins to grow and dominate the world TKD arena.
It also announces that it will take in other styles of non-ITF TKD
stylists. Always quelled and snubbed off by ITF, they joined the ranks of
WTF organization. Some who did not agree with WTF politics later reverted
back to their own styles, but this time, did not have to be constantly
aware of ITF TKD s snubbing attitudes.
General Choi upon hearing the news feels taken advantage of what was
justifiably his work with his opponents taking credit for his work. It
becomes a severe blow for him, for what he had spent so much of his life
on, was gone. One of his lifetime dreams, the inclusion of ITF style TKD
into the Olympics has now become an illusion.
ITF assessment of WTF
stylists:
All they do is fancy foot and legwork with a lot of sound.
No real power. Everything is geared to competition and tournaments. No
spiritual arts, and a lot of good foot techniques such as twisting front
kick(a kick that springs up from a standing position both feet facing
forward, foot is twisted inwards and kicked up towards the opponents
nosebridge at an angle)are lost, and everything is competition oriented.
The practicality of the martial arts is lost for speed and points in
tournaments. Upper body and hand movements are not emphasized nor does it
call for hitting/striking the face/head as in real fighting, or close
range when someone is tackled. Thus the students are only skilled in
playing tag points . No real practical value in actual fighting. The head
of WTF is not a TKD practitioner but a bureaucratic figurehead which is
why WTF certificates are signed Dr. Un Young Kim. He has neither
demonstrated nor taught TKD. The WTF patterns are of no aesthetic value,
it is just a breakdown mix and match of ITF forms. No beauty in forms.
Taekwondo? Gaekwondo is more like it.(Note: Gae is dog in Korean,
loosely translated, it means dog pawing ).
WTF assessment of ITF
stylists:
Outdated and limited
kicking techniques taught by old masters that have no practical
application & imagination for WTF sparring. Non contact or light contact
pussy footers -because one is conditioned to fight non-contact or light
contact, they get blown away in real hard full contact sparring
situations. Impractical sparring moves-eg. blocking instead of dodging.
Moves are too slow for practicality and vulnerable. (e.g. plain wheel
kick, where the heel is turned in an arc towards the opponent s head by
turning back without hooking at the knee ). Too low and wide stances that
slows down each movement and telegraphs your move. No power nor speed in
moves. No efficient aerial kick techniques that require high skill which
can be devastating,. No innovations or development in their moves. Thus
the students have limited skills. ITF TKD? Gimme a break.
Rules of WTF(simplified terms).
WTF sparring is tournament oriented.
1. Hits must be on the certain target areas above the waist
line for points.
2. No punches allowed to the face. If punch is done to the body, one must
hit to the body with a forcible impact to the opponent.
3. Kicks to the head allowed.
4. No grabbing or holding the opponent.
5. No points for hitting in the back.
6. No sweeps or take downs.
7. Protective gear (including forearm, shin, head, chest, and groin
protection )and now doboks must be sanctioned by WTF
Rules of ITF(simple
terms).
ITF is traditional training oriented. Tournament Rules
(Again, this is general and varies in each splintered ITF-style group).
1. Protective gear required(the level of protection depends on the
instructor).
2. Light padding on shins, knees, foot, and arms.
3. Light head gear.
4. Timed sparring.
5. Points for certain targets including hand techniques. Stopped for
points(in some).
6. Non, light, or medium contact. (Full contact is rare, but is allowed in
some tournaments).
7. Chest protector(depends on instructor).
The real difference
between ITF and WTF
ITF
being traditional adheres to an equal emphasis on patterns, breaking,
sparring, & self-defense techniques. WTF has more emphasis on sparring
aspect than patterns and self-defense. That is not to say WTF does not
have patterns or self-defense. Breaking in WTF however, is not much
emphasized as breaking in ITF.
Which is better? In my opinion, the objectives of ITF and WTF are
different. ITF(traditional martial art TKD) and WTF(tournament geared TKD)
are two different systems that has diverged from the same origin. The
best answer would be the better TKD stylist. The question is more like who
is the better player? Comparing the better squash player vs. the better
racquet ball player IMHO does not do justify who is better, even though
the game may be similar.